At 4533 Corsican Loop E in M/I Homes' Hill Farm community, a finished Charleston-plan home is marked "Ready Now." The asking price was $532,883 and is now $489,883. That $43,000 cut, about 8% off the original price, sits on a builder's website where anyone can see it.
In October, Hilliard's resale market showed nothing like it. Homes inside the city limits took longer to sell and piled up on the market. Sellers who closed still got 98.5% of their original list price, slightly more than they got in October 2025. Hilliard resale sellers are handling the slower market by waiting longer for their price, while the builders are paying for sales with cuts and credits that expire on fixed dates.
The resale market slowed in volume and held its prices
The Columbus REALTORS October 2026 Local Market Update for Hilliard (Corp.) covers homes inside the city's corporate limits. It shows 20 closed sales in October, down from 43 in October 2025. Homes under contract fell from 46 to 31 over the same comparison. New listings also fell, from 48 to 39. Inventory still rose to 97 homes from 67 a year earlier, and months' supply went from 1.8 to 2.6. Fewer homes came on the market, but even fewer sold, so the unsold ones added up.
Sellers have not responded by pricing lower. The median list price of new listings in October was $439,900, up 4.1% from October 2025. Median days on market until sale rose from 26 to 30. The October median sale price was $402,000, down 3.1% from a year earlier. Through the first ten months of 2026, the median was $430,000, down 5.9% from the same stretch of 2025, on 378 closings compared with 368.
These numbers have two limits. First, the report states that its prices do not account for sale concessions. A seller who paid toward a buyer's closing costs shows up at the full contract price. Second, the samples are small enough to swing. September 2026 had 40 closings at a $515,000 median, with 24 days on market and 92 homes in inventory. The broader Hilliard City School District report for October 2026 covers more ground. It shows 66 closings, a $397,000 median, 35 days on market and inventory down 4.1% from a year earlier, at 1.9 months of supply. The pattern in the city-limits figures still holds across both months: inventory went up, and the share of asking price that sellers received did not go down.
Builders are absorbing the slowdown with dated incentives
Hilliard's active new-construction communities are competing on price cuts, closing-cost money and advertised rates. Most of those incentives carry a contract or closing deadline. Here is how they stood in mid-November 2026, as each builder advertised them.
| Community | Location | Advertised price | Incentive as of mid-November 2026 | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hill Farm, M/I Homes | Near Elliott, Scioto Darby and Langton roads | From $459,900 | Up to $30,000 flex cash on Retreat and Signature homes, up to $25,000 on Smart Essentials and Premier homes, plus up to $6,500 toward closing costs through M/I Financial | New contracts Nov. 9 to Dec. 20, 2026, closing on or after Feb. 1, 2027 |
| Retreat at Sugar Farms, Pulte | Hilliard | From $399,990 | First-year rate of 2.99%, 6.157% APR, on certain move-in-ready homes | Contracted on or after Nov. 7, closed by Dec. 31, 2026 |
| Alton Place, Fischer Homes | Off Roberts Road | From $678,990 | Five-year rate of 4.99%, 6.599% APR, on select move-in-ready homes | Must close by Nov. 30, 2026 |
| The Courtyards at Carr Farms, Epcon | Off Leppert Road | Low $400,000s to low $700,000s | Price protection if a home's base price falls during construction | Ongoing as listed |
Pulte has also scheduled a one-week Early Black Friday promotion at Retreat at Sugar Farms for Nov. 15 to 21, with up to $30,000 in options and up to $10,000 toward closing costs through Pulte Mortgage. A seven-day window like that one is how short some of these builder terms run.
The incentives also interact. M/I's terms say flex cash applies to select quick move-in homes that can close on or after Feb. 1, 2027. If a home's price has already been reduced, as at Corsican Loop E, the credit is adjusted. The price cut and the holiday credit don't stack in full. Hill Farm's other quick move-in homes list at $510,265 for 4541 Corsican Loop E and $518,810 for 4532 Nonius Drive.
The rates and credits above are as each builder advertised them in mid-November 2026. Builders change them often. This post is general information, not financial or legal advice, so confirm any loan terms or credits for your own situation with your lender and other qualified professionals.
Where new-construction prices fall against the resale median
Hilliard's new construction spans a wide range of prices, so builder prices don't compare to the resale median as one group.
Pulte's Retreat at Sugar Farms starts at $399,990, just under October's $402,000 city-limits median. Epcon's Carr Farms starts in the low $400,000s. M/I's Hill Farm base price of $459,900 is about 14% above the median. Fischer's Alton Place starts at $678,990, and its two quick move-in homes list at $819,990 for the Clay plan at 6833 Northfield Place and $864,990 for the Pearson plan at 6864 Northfield Place. Fischer lists both as available in 30 days. Epcon's two listed Portico homes are $649,350 at 4837 Diplomat Way, listed as available in December 2026, and $669,345 at 5656 Embassy Drive, listed as available in February 2027.
A base price is the cheapest version of the cheapest plan before options. The resale median covers every kind of home that closed that month. Neither is a like-for-like comparison. They do show that a buyer near Hilliard's median price can find new construction at Sugar Farms or Carr Farms, while Alton Place is a different price tier.
What the location trade-off looks like on the map
Each of these communities is in a part of Hilliard that is still growing, so a new-construction buyer is also buying into ongoing construction nearby.
Hill Farm is near Elliott, Scioto Darby and Langton roads. The city described its first phase as 229 single-family lots on 204 acres. A proposed expansion adds 300 lots on 265 acres, 186 of them set aside as open space. The Columbus Dispatch reported in March 2025 that City Council approved the expansion rezoning by a 5–2 vote. M/I describes the community as having 3.5 miles of trails that connect to Homestead Metro Park.
Fischer's Alton Place is part of a larger plan. The Dispatch reported in August 2025 that the broader Alton Place development covers 345 acres and plans 30 to 40 shops, along with a separate 123-home project by Onyx+East that was expected to come online in 2027. A city staff report for an Aug. 13, 2026 meeting describes those 123 homes, on 31.92 acres at 2717 Alton Darby Road, as an approved development. The city also scheduled Roberts Road corridor work tied to Alton Place to begin Sept. 21, 2026, with the developer planning work through the fall. Someone buying on Northfield Place this winter is moving into a master plan whose shops are still planned and whose next 123 homes are approved.
Epcon places Carr Farms about two miles from downtown Hilliard and two and a half miles from the Heritage Rail Trail. Its homes run from 1,418 to 4,060 square feet, with ranch homes and townhomes built around private garden courtyards. If you want to be near Old Hilliard's restaurants and Thursday nights downtown, which we covered in our look at Hilliard's two restaurant corridors, the resale side of the market is where established homes closer to downtown come up.
How the deadlines line up for a winter purchase
The builder deadlines are close together. Fischer's rate requires closing by Nov. 30. Pulte's runs through Dec. 31 closings. M/I's covers contracts written by Dec. 20 that close in February or later. Fischer's window is measured in days, Pulte's in weeks, and M/I's asks a buyer to sign before the holidays and close after them. Epcon's price protection is the one incentive in the group without a published end date.
Resale works on a different clock. With 2.6 months of supply and 97 homes for sale inside the city limits in October, a buyer had more homes to compare than a year earlier, and homes were taking longer to sell. In October, sellers still received 99.7% of their last list price, and for the year through October the figure was 100.2%. The room to negotiate on a resale home in Hilliard comes mostly from the days the home has been on the market, which differ from house to house. With builders, it comes from a promotion calendar anyone can read.
For a broader comparison of Hilliard with Dublin, Upper Arlington and the other northwest suburbs, see how Hilliard housing compares to other northwest Columbus suburbs and our Hilliard neighborhood page.
Quick answers
Did Hilliard home prices fall in October 2026? Slightly. The median sale price inside the city limits was $402,000 in October 2026, down 3.1% from October 2025. The median list price of new listings rose 4.1% over the same comparison, to $439,900.
Is new construction in Hilliard more expensive than resale? It depends on the community. In mid-November 2026, advertised starting prices ranged from $399,990 at Retreat at Sugar Farms to $678,990 at Alton Place, compared with an October resale median of $402,000 inside the city limits.
How long are Hilliard homes taking to sell? Homes inside the city limits that sold in October 2026 took a median of 30 days, compared with 26 days in October 2025. Across the wider Hilliard City School District, the figure was 35 days.
If you're comparing a Hill Farm quick move-in home with a resale home a few miles closer to Old Hilliard this winter, the numbers that matter are the builder's contract and closing dates on one side and the seller's days on market on the other. Greg Giessler and the team at Cam Taylor Realtors are glad to walk through both with you. If you own in Hilliard and are deciding whether to list into this market or wait for spring, start with a free home valuation and a conversation about where your home would have fit among the 97 homes for sale in October.